MEDIA REPRESENTATIONS OF WOMEN AND MAN AS ACTORS OR VICTIMS INVOLVED IN HOMICIDAL VIOLENCE
Keywords:
homicidal violence, homicide, media representation, gender stereotypeAbstract
This paper is devoted to the analysis of media representations of homicidal violence in the Republic of Serbia, with specific focus on their gender dimension. Quantitative-qualitative content analysis and discourse analysis of media narratives on homicidal violence encompassed online texts in selected Serbian dailies, and was carried out on the sample of newspaper articles published from May 1, 2019, to October 31, 2019. The results showed that article authors’ moralistic judgment derived from their social/gender stereotypes, and subjective perception of social deviance - that is reflected through simplified and biased presentation of the actors and victims, and implicitly suggesting to the audience with whom of them they should empathize with – is marked characteristic of those texts reporting on the lethal violence conducted by males against the intimate partner or family member. It was confirmed what has been described in the literature before, that women committed lethal violence are commonly represented as “fatal beauties”, “bad wives”, or “bad mothers”. Bearing in mind that media plays an important role in “knowledge construction” and significantly influences both the public attitudes and policies, it seems crucial that media is aware of their capacity and improve their practices in this area, including the reporting about violence without creating or preserving wrong beliefs or harmful social and gender stereotypes and biases.
Downloads
References
Alo (2019): Zavidela manekenki na lepoti: Jelisaveta (22) zbog ljubomore krvnički ubila sestru Stefaniju (17)!, 24. oktobar [online]. Preuzeto 25.10.2019. sa: https://www.alo.rs/vesti/svet/jelisaveta-22-zbog-ljubomore-krvnicki-ubila-sestru-stefaniju-17-kopirala-je-usvemu-a-jedan-detalj-je-posebno-bolestan-foto-video/260693/vest
Alo/Republika/V.M (2019): Oličenje demona, divljao je kao razjarena zver: Marko je svirepo ubio majku, a onda vikao: “Ja sam Isus i moram da namirim trojstvo”, Alo, 5. oktobar [online]. Preuzeto 11.10.2019. sa: https://www.alo.rs/vesti/hronika/marko-jesvirepo-ubio-majku-a-onda-vikao-ja-sam-isus-i-moram-da-namirim-trojstvo/256610/vest
Berger, J. (1972): Ways of Seeing. London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin Books Ltd. Preuzeto 2.11.2019. sa http://waysofseeingwaysofseeing.com/ways-of-seeing-john-berger-5.7.pdf
Blic (2019): Gost ubio konobara jer je dugo čekao sendvič, 17. avgust [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.blic.rs/vesti/svet/gost-ubio-konobara-jer-je-dugo-cekaosendvic/js3bql3
Blic (2019): Klale, pucale, trovale: Ruke ovih žena krvavije su od mnogih ozloglašenih ubica, a evo šta se sa njima dogodilo nakon zločina, 1. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.blic.rs/vesti/hronika/klale-pucale-trovale-ruke-ovih-zenakrvavije-su-od-mnogih-ozloglasenih-ubica-a-evo/s3gvb1x
Blic (2019): Bebi slomljena lobanja – Nastavljeno suđenje ocu monstrumu koji je ubio petomesečnog sina, 16. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 10.10.2019. sa: https://www.blic.rs/vesti/republika-srpska/bebi-slomljena-lobanja-nastavljeno-sudenjeocu-monstrumu-koji-je-ubio-petomesecnog/j91l3n3
Blic (2019): Majka koja je ćutala dok joj je dečko krvnički nasmrt pretukao ćerku (2,5) puštena na slobodu, 21. oktobar [online]. Preuzeto 25.10.2019. sa: https://www.blic.rs/vesti/hronika/skandalozna-odluka-suda-u-negotinu-majka-koja-jecutala-dok-joj-je-decko-krvnicki/s8kt4yr
Blic (2019): Natalija zajedno sa dečkom pretukla svoju bebu, kojoj je on potom odrubio glavu: Lekari pali u nesvest zbog stravičnog prizora, 29. oktobar [online]. Preuzeto 25.10.2019. sa: https://www.blic.rs/vesti/svet/natalija-zajedno-sa-deckom-pretukla-svojubebu-kojoj-je-on-potom-odbrubio-glavu/cf7gm53
Blic/Gubelić, M.Č. (2019): Blic, “Sanja je objavila snimak iz provoda s nevenčanim mužem, tri sada kasnije on ju je ubio, jer 'nije htela da spava s njim"', Blic, 17. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 6.10.2019. sa: https://www.blic.rs/vesti/hronika/sanja-je-objavilasnimak-iz-provoda-s-nevencanim-muzem-tri-sada-kasnije-on-ju-je-ubio/69h17m2
Brennan, P. K., Vandenberg, A. L. (2009): Depictions of Female Offenders in Front-Page Newspaper Stories: The Importance of Race/Ethnicity, International Journal of Social Inquiry, 2(2): 141-175.
Chermak, S. (1994): Body count news: How crime is presented in the news media. Justice Quarterly, 11: 561-582.
Chesney-Lind, M. (1999): Media misogyny: Demonizing “violent” girls and women. In Ferrell, J., Websdale, N. (eds.), Making trouble: Cultural constructions of crime, deviance and control (pp. 115-140). New York: Walter de Gruyter, Inc.
Estrada, F., Nilsson, A. (2012): Does it cost more to be a female offender? A life-course study of childhood circumstances, crime, drug abuse, and living conditions, Feminist Criminology, 7(3): 196–219.
Estrada, F., Nilsson, A., Pettersson, T. (2019): The female offender - A century of registered crime and daily press reporting on women’s crime, Nordic Journal of Criminology, 20(2): 138-156.
Fairbairn, J., Myrna D. (2013): Canadian news coverage of intimate partner homicide: Analyzing changes over time, Feminist Criminology, 8(3): 147-176.
Garofolo, J. (1981): Crime and the mass media: A selective review of research, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 18(2): 319-350.
Gavrilov, N. (2019): Bratoubica upisao psihologiju, briljirao na prijemnom: Bogdan se ćutanjem branio na sudu, misle da nije bio pri sebi!. Alo [online], 21. avgust. Preuzeto 2.10.2019. sa: https://www.alo.rs/vesti/hronika/bogdan-se-cutanjem-branio-na-sudumisle-da-nije-bio-pri-sebi-gradom-se-cuju-svakakve-price-jedno-je-posebna-misterijafoto/247896/vest
Jewkes, Y. (2015): Media and Crime (3rd ed.). London: Sage Publications.
Johnstone, J. W. C., Hawkins, D. F., Michener, A. (1994): Homicide reporting in Chicago dailies, Journalism Quarterly, 71(4): 860-872.
Jorgačević, J, prir. (2016): „Prinošenje žrtava na oltar senzacionalizma“, Tribina Mediji i nasilje u porodici, u: Vreme protiv nasilja – Dodatak nedeljnika Vreme, br. 1343, 29. septembar 2016.
Kurir (2019): Prijatelj svedočio o pozadini ubistva žene: Svaki dan mi je čitao pisma koja joj je slao i molio je da se pomire! Njeni odgovori su ga vređali jer su počinjali sa "poštovani"!, 24. maj [online]. Preuzeto 10.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/crnahronika/3256533/prijatelj-svedocio-o-pozadini-ubistva-zene-svaki-dan-mi-je-citaopisma-koja-joj-je-slao-i-molio-je-da-se-pomire-njeni-odgovori-su-ga-vredjali-jer-supocinjali-sa-postovani
Kurir (2019): Kamere snimile likvidaciju na Novom Beogradu: Advokat s fantomkom iskočio iz mraka i bivšoj sasuo šest hitaca u leđa!, 26. maj [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/crna-hronika/3257859/kamere-sinimile-likvidaciju-na-novombeogradu-advokat-s-fantomkom-iskocio-iz-mraka-i-bivsoj-sasuo-sest-hitaca-u-ledja
Kurir (2019): Ovo je monstrum od majke: Ubila dve male ćerke jer su joj smetale da se prostituiše!, 3. jul [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/planeta/3279125/majka-mucki-usmrtila-svoje-dve-cerke-smetale-sujoj-da-se-prostituise-pa-ih-ubila-u-razmaku-od-18-dana-foto
Kurir (2019): Majka (23) proglašena krivom za ubistva dve ćerke: Ugušila je devojčice jer su joj smetala da se bavi prostitucijom!, 2. avgust [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/planeta/3296203/majka-23-proglasena-krivom-za-ubistva-dvecerke-ugusila-je-devojcice-jer-su-joj-smetala-da-se-bavi-prostitucijom-ni-u-jednommomentu-nije-pokazala-emocije-foto
Kurir (2019): Srbin, Italijan i Rumun se svađali ko je lepši, a onda je usledio krvavi zločin: Ivan (34) ubio Italijana posle svađe u seoskoj kafani?! Detalji bizarnog ubistva u Bolonji!, 4. avgust [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/crnahronika/3297183/krvavi-zlocin-potresao-bolonju-srbin-ubio-italijana
Kurir (2019): Monstrum poslao dečaka (10) da vidi ko je sve u kući, pa ga prvog ubio, 5. avgust [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/region/hrvatska/3298195/monstrum-poslao-decaka-10-da-vidi-ko-jesve-u-kuci-pa-ga-prvog-ubio-novi-jezivi-detalji-otkrivaju-sta-se-dogadjalo-pre-krvavognapada-u-zagrebu
Kurir (2019): Svirepi ubica bio opsednut religijom i satanizmom: Ikonopisac izgubio razum, pa ubio babu u Nišu, kao u knjizi Zločin i kazna!, 5. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 10.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/crna-hronika/3316139/novi-detalji-svirepog-zlocinau-nisu-ubio-babukao-u-knjizi-zlocin-i-kazna
Kurir (2019): Otac monstrum je zverski ubio ovog malog anđela! Zavitlao sinčića (1) u reku i mrtav hladan otišao na pivo!, 12. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 11.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/planeta/3320381/otac-monstrum-je-zverski-ubio-ovog-malogandjela-zavitlao-sincica-1-u-reku-i-mrtav-hladan-otisao-na-pivo-video
Kurir (2019): Izvinite, upravo sam vam ubio ćerku: Amerikanac izbo svoju devojku, pa od njenog oca tražio nešto nečuveno, 24. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 2.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/planeta/3326995/izvinite-upravo-sam-vam-ubio-cerku-amerikanacizbo-svoju-devojku-pa-od-njenog-oca-trazio-nesto-necuveno-video
Kurir (2019): Fatalna Sunita Hindić (21) se predala! Osumnjičena da je ubila mostarskog tajkuna!, 6. oktobar [online]. Preuzeto 6.10.2019. sa: https://www.kurir.rs/crnahronika/3334443/fatalna-bosanka-21-se-predala-policiji-misica-polomila-noge-bezeciod-policije
Kurir/Alo.rs (2019): Detalji porodične drame u Kraljevu: “Čuo sam Marinin vrisak, a onda sam ga zatekao mrtvog u fotelji”. Komšije misle da je Saša poludeo zbog vrućine, pa krenuo da puca!, Alo, 14. avgust [online]. Preuzeto 2.10.2019. sa: https://www.alo.rs/vesti/hronika/cuo-sam-marinin-vrisak-a-onda-sam-ga-zatekao-mrtvogu-fotelji-komsije-misle-da-je-sasa-poludeo-zbog-vrucine-pa-krenuo-da-puca/246477/vest
Kurir/Blic (2019): Došla sa slave, porodila se, pa zadavila bebu: Porodilji iz sela kod Valjeva određen pritvor, otkriveni novi detalji zločina, Blic, 9. maj [online]. Preuzeto 2.10.2019. sa: https://www.blic.rs/vesti/hronika/dosla-sa-slave-porodila-se-pa-zadavilabebu-porodilji-iz-sela-kod-valjeva-odreden/xh3h4j7
Lee, C., Wong, J. (2019): 99 Reasons and He Ain’t One: A Content Analysis of Domestic Homicide News Coverage, Violence against Women, pp. 1-20.
Maguire, B., Sandage, D., Weatherby, G. A. (1999): Crime stories as television news: A content analysis of national big city and small town newscasts, Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture, 7: 1-14.
Milovanović, I., Vujović, M. (2014): Vizuelna reprezentacija žene u ženskoj štampi, u: Valić Nedeljković, D., Pralica, D. (ur.) Digitalne medijske tehnologije i društveno obrazovne promene, 4, Novi Sad: Filozofski fakultet Univerziteta, str. 121-132.
Mršević, Z. (2013): Kvalitativna analiza medijskog izveštavanja o nasilju nad ženama u Srbiji. Beograd: Program Ujedinjenih nacija za razvoj (UNDP).
Mršević, Z. (2019): Nasilje i mi: Mediji o nasilju nad ženama. Beograd: Institut društvenih nauka.
Naylor, B. (2001): Reporting violence in the British print media: Gendered stories, The Howard Journal, 40(2): 180-194.
Novosti (2019): Naložena obdukcija Vasiljkovića: Izbo suprugu pa se obesio?, 25. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: www.novosti.rs/vesti/naslovna/hronika/aktuelno.291.html:820520-NALOZENAOBDUKCIJA-VASILjKOVICA-Izbo-suprugu-pa-se-obesio
Novosti/Alo (2019): Bela Palanka zavijena u crno: Ovo je Tanja koju je muž izbo nasmrt! Komšije dale skandaloznu izjavu, Alo, 25. septembar [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.alo.rs/vesti/hronika/ovo-je-tanja-koju-je-muz-izbo-nasmrt-komsije-daleskandaloznu-izjavu-foto/254638/vest
Republički zavod za statistiku (2018): Punoletni učinioci krivičnih dela u Republici Srbiji, 2017: Prijave, optuženja i osude. Bilten br. 643, Beograd.
Telegraf (2019): Prvi serijski ubica u Srbiji je baba Anujka iz okoline Pančeva: Ubila je 150 ljudi, davala im ovu čudnu vodicu, 04. maj [online]. Preuzeto 2.10.2019. sa: https://www.telegraf.rs/vesti/srbija/3057626-prvi-serijski-ubica-u-srbiji-je-vestica-izokoline-panceva-ubila-je-150-ljudi-i-nikad-nije-imala-grizu-savesti-video
Telegraf (2019): Valerija (12) se pohvalila u školi da je probala ljudski mozak: Policija je otkrila da je ona s pedofilom ubila čoveka i - pojela ga, 7. maj [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.telegraf.rs/vesti/svet/3058578-valerija-12-se-pohvalila-uskoli-da-je-probala-ljudski-mozak-policija-je-otkrila-da-je-ona-s-pedofilom-ubilacoveka-i-pojela-ga
Telegraf (2019): Priznao da je polio benzinom i zapalio suprugu Slavicu jer je često izlazila s prijateljicama, 28. maj [online]. Preuzeto 30.09.2019. sa: https://www.telegraf.rs/vesti/hronika/3065785-priznao-da-je-polio-benzinom-i-zapaliosuprugu-slavicu-jer-je-cesto-izlazila-s-prijateljicama
Telegraf (2019): Ubila prijateljicu na Aljasci: Nepoznat "milijarder" joj obećao mnogo novca za snimke njenog leša, 19. jun [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.telegraf.rs/vesti/svet/3073322-ubila-prijateljicu-na-aljasci-nepoznatmilijarder-joj-obecao-mnogo-novca-za-snimke-njenog-lesa
Telegraf (2019): "Ja sam te rodila i odgajila, a ti me mrziš i na kraju me ubiješ": Zašto srpski sinovi ubijaju majke, 4. oktobar [online]. Preuzeto 10.10.2019. sa: https://www.telegraf.rs/vesti/srbija/3108962-ja-sam-te-rodila-i-odgajila-a-ti-me-mrzis-ina-kraju-me-ubijes-zasto-srpski-sinovi-ubijaju-majke
Telegraf.rs/Gazeta.ru (2019): Stjuardesa pronađena mrtva u moskovskom hotelu, sumnja se da ju je ubio ljubomorni dečko, Telegraf, 14. jul [online]. Preuzeto 1.10.2019. sa: https://www.telegraf.rs/vesti/svet/3081967-stjuardesa-pronadjena-mrtva-u-moskovskomhotelu-sumnja-se-da-ju-je-ubio-ljubomorni-decko
Skilbrei, M-L. (2012): Sisters in crime: Representations of gender and class in the media coverage and court proceedings of the triple homicide at Orderud Farm, Crime, Media, Culture, 9(2): 136–152.
Vučić, M. (2019): „Mizogino izveštavanje: Ubio ženu jer mu je dala povoda“, Raskrinkavanje, 27.05.2019. Preuzeto 10.10.2019. sa https://www.raskrikavanje.rs/page.php?id=445
Wong, S.J., Lee, C. (2018): Extra! Extra! The Importance of Victim–Offender Relationship in Homicide Newsworthiness, Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 1–21.












