COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE “SERBIAN WORLD” AND “GREATER SERBIA” CONCEPTS

Aleksandar Ljubomirović

doi:10.51738/Kpolisa2024.21.3r.122lj

Authors

Aleksandar Ljubomirović Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development, Belgrade Faculty of Political Sciences, Belgrade https://orcid.org/0009-0003-5932-7438

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.51738/Kpolisa2024.21.3r.122lj

Keywords:

Serbian world, Greater Serbia, concepts, greater-state projects, borders

Abstract

This article aims to present designated outcomes of the author’s research on the Serbian world concept, which surfaced as an indispensable part of the public discourse in the year 2020, and has been ever since repeatedly identified with the notion of “Greater Serbia”. Hence, the methodology of the comparative analysis will be applied with the intention of systematically examining the resemblances and differences of the said concepts, including also elements of the qualitative content analysis. The qualitative content analysis includes pre-selected public statements of prominent regional stakeholders in which they identify the Serbian world with the “Greater Serbia” concept. This represents a significant approach for the understanding of the Serbian world per se and its comparison with other note-worthy concepts, because it is still regarded mainly as a mental construct. Therefore, whilst analysing this concept the focus must be placed on processes of mental shaping of the world as understood by the participants of the discourse, and on the process of the conceptualization of reality. Based on the results of the analysis, the author concludes that only its opponents regard the Serbian world as a modernized version of “Greater Serbia” with the purpose of discrediting the newly popularized term, and for which they assume will have an exclusively territorial connotation with imperial pretensions. However, the analysis has shown that the constant comparisons with “Greater Serbia” are part of an ongoing anti-Serbian campaign, and that the concept was not designed after any greater-state ideas. The Serbian world concept has a predominantly cultural dimension, with a focus on the promotion of the ‘world of values’ of the Serbian people.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Aktuelno. (2021, 18 May). Džaferović za beogradski ’Danas’: ’Srpski svet’ treba ozbiljno shvatiti, to je samo drugi naziv za Veliku Srbiju. https://sandzackenovine.rs/dzaferovic-za-beogradskidanas-srpski-svet-treba-ozbiljno-shvatiti-to-je-samo-drugi-nazivza-veliku-srbiju/.

Al Jazeera. (2021, 19 July). Critics condemn minister’s call to unite ’Serb world’. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/7/19/critics-condemnministers-call-to-unite-serbian.

Antić, Č. & Kecmanović, N. (2016). Istorija Republike Srpske [History of the Republic of Srpska]. Službeni glasnik Republike Srpske.

Antić, Č. (Ed.). (2021). Izveštaj o političkim pravima srpskog naroda u regionu: Izveštaj za 2020/2021 [Report on the Political Rights of the Serbian People in The Region: Report for 2020/2021]. Broj XIII. Napredni klub.

Antić, Č. & Marković, J. P. (2023). Novi srpski istorijski atlas [New Serbian Historical Atlas]. Institut za savremenu istoriju.

Avdić, A. (2023, 3 April). Evropa (i) SAD u crnogorskom ruskom ruletu: Sad će opet Crna Gora bit obala srpskog mora. Istraga. https://istraga.ba/evropa-i-sad-u-crnogorskom-ruskom-ruletusad-ce-opet-crna-gora-bit-obala-srpskog-mora/.

Avijucki, V. (2009). Kontinentalne geopolitike: Svet u XXI veku [Continental Geopolitics: The World in the 21st Century]. Clio.

Beta. (2021, 13 April). Montenegro’s President: Greater Serbia’s nationalism has malignant effect. https://n1info.rs/english/news/montenegros-president-greaterserbias-nationalism-has-malignant-effect/.

Beta. (2021b, 20 July). Izetbegović: Srpski svet je ime za Veliku Srbiju, od Vučića očekujem da ne ćuti. N1. https://n1info.rs/region/bakir-izetbegovic-srpski-svet-jedrugo-ime-za-veliku-srbiju/.

Beta. (2024, 3 April). Dodik: Naš glavni grad je Beograd, nikakvo Sarajevo. https://www.danas.rs/svet/region/dodik-beogradglavni-grad/.

Biserko, S. (2022). Srpski svet [Serbian World]. Međunarodni forum Bosna, 97(1), 132–144.

Borba. (2021, 30 October). Raković za Al Džaziru: Srpski svet je superiorna i plemenita ideja. https://borba.me/rakovic-za-aldzaziru-srpski-svet-je-superiorna-i-plemenita-ideja/.

Brey, T. (2022). Staatsziel Revisionismus: Die Jugoslawienkriege und Russlands Angriff auf die Ukraine [Revisionism As a State Goal: The Yugoslav Wars and Russia’s Attack on Ukraine]. Südosteuropa Mitteilungen, 4(1), 36–45.

Cocq, C. C. & Szekely, O. (2021). Comparative Analysis. In J. Morin, C. Olsson & E. Ö. Atikcan, Research Methods in the Social Sciences: An A-Z of key concepts. Oxford University Press.

Della Porta, D. & Keating, M. (Eds). (2008). Approaches and Methodologies in the Social Sciences: A Pluralist Perspective. Cambridge University Press.

Digital Forensic Center [DFC]. (2021, 15 April). The Serbian World – Originally Borrowed Concept: DFC analysis of the attempt to merge Montenegro into the Serbian world. https://dfc.me/en/publikacije/the-serbian-world-an-originallyborrowed-concept/.

Drobnič, S. (2014). Comparative Analysis. In A. Michalos (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-Being Research. Springer.

Ekmečić, M. (2002). Dijalog prošlosti i sadašnjosti [Dialog Between The Past And The Present]. Službeni list SRJ.

Garašanin, I. (2016). Načertanije Ilije Garašanina: program spoljašne i nacionalne politike Srbije na koncu 1884. godine [Ilija Garašanin’s Načertanije: The Program of Serbia’s Foreign and National Policy at the end of 1884]. Ethos.

Gheyle, N. & Jacobs, T. (2017). Content Analysis: a short overview. Internal research note.

IN4S. (2021). Kako je nastao Srpski sv(ij)et: Raičević, Bokan, Dobrosavljević i Raković na Nacionalnoj TV. https://www.in4s.net/video-kako-je-nastao-srpski-svijetraicevic-bokan-dobrosavljevic-i-rakovic-na-nacionalnoj-tv/.

Jadovno. (2021). Miljan Glišić: Srpski svet i snaga jednog naroda, svedočenje kako je nastala aktuelna upotreba sintagme ’Srpski svet’. https://jadovno.com/miljan -glisic-srpski-svet-i-snagajednog-naroda/#.Yz2jjHZBy5c.

Karabeg, O. (2021, 25 July). Most: Pokušava li Vučić da bude ’predsednik svih Srba’?. Radio Slobodna Evropa. https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/most-vucic-srpskisvet/31375113.html.

Karčić, H. (2023, 24 April). Serbia Is Taking a Page Out of Russia’s Book. Foreign Policy. https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/04/24/serbia-balkansexpansionism-russia-montenegro-elections/.

Kentera, S. (Ed.). (2021). Uloga Rusije na Balkanu: slučaj Crne Gore [The Role of Russia In The Balkans: The Case of Montenegro]. Digitalni forenzički centar.

Kosachev, K. (2012). The Specifics of Russian Soft Power. Russia in Global Affairs, 3(1), 1–11. https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/articles/the-specifics-of-russiansoft-power/.

Kozdra, M. (2018). The Boundaries of Russian Identity: Analysis of the Concept of Russkiy Mir in Contemporary Russian Online Media. Lingua Cultura, 12(1), 61–66.

Krestić, Dj. V. (1998). Genocidom do Velike Hrvatske [Through Genocide Towards a Greater Croatia]. Matica Srpska.

Krestić, Dj. V. & Nedić, M. (Eds.). (2003). The Great Serbia: Truth, Blundersm Abuses. Srpska književna zadruga.

Krippendort, K. (2004). Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology. The Annenberg School for Communication.

Laruelle, M. (2015). The Russian World: Russia’s Soft Power and Geopolitical Imagination. Center on Global Interests.

Ljubomirović, A. (2024). Stvaranje ’Srpskog sveta’ – kvalitativna analiza sadržaja javnih iskaza o konceptu i definisanje njegovih dimenzija [Creating the „Serbian World“: Qualitative Content Analysis of Public Statements Regarding the Concept And Defining Its Dimensions]. Nacionalni interes, 48(2), 105–133.

Ljušić, R. (2004). Knjiga o Načertaniju [A Book About Načertanije]. Beletra.

Marković, R. (2020). Đukanović: Srpski svet je eufemizam za ideju velike Srbije. Dnevni list Danas. https://www.danas.rs/svet/djukanovicsrpski-svet-je-eufemizam-za-ideju-velike-srbije/.

Martens, M. (2023, 5 July). Vorteil Serbien. Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung [FAZ]. https://www.faz.net/aktuell/politik/ausland/kriseam-balkan-vorteil-serbien-19002636.html.

Ministarstvo odbrane Republike Srbije [MORS]. (2020). Ministar Vulin: Srbi moraju da postanu jedinstven politički narod. https://www.mod.gov.rs/eng/16537/ministar-vulin-srbi-morajuda-postanu-jedinstven-politicki-narod-16537.

Mulaosmanović, A. (2021). Die Serbische Welt des Aleksandar Vučić: Tausend Gesichter und die Handschrift des Grossserbischen Traums [The Serbian World of Aleksandar Vučić: Thousand Faces and The Signature of The Greater Serbian Dream]. Pangea Research Institute.

Nikolaidis, A. (2020, 20 July). Ko će to još povjerovati u novu ‘veliku Srbiju’. Al Jazeera. https://balkans.aljazeera.net/opinions/2020/7/20/ko-ce-jospovjerovati-u-novu-veliku-srbiju.

Novosti Online. (2021, 25 September). Srpsko ujedinjenje – Superiorna ideja: Istoričar Aleksandar Raković na HRT-u o konceptu oko kog se digla velika prašina. https://www.novosti.rs/c/vesti/politika/1039443/srpskoujedinjenje-superiorna-ideja-istoricar-aleksandar-rakovic-hrtkonceptu-oko-kog-digla-velika-prasina.

Pešić, M. (2018, 5 August). Srbi u regionu – između asimilacije i opstanka. Politka Online. https://www.politika.rs/scc/clanak/408661/Srbi-u-regionuizmedu-asimilacije-i-opstanka#google_vignette.

Pobjeda. (2020, 17 November). Raković: A federal state comprising Montenegro, Serbia and Republika Srpska should be set up. CDM. https://www.cdm.me/english/rakovic-a-federal-statecomprising-montenegro-serbia-and-republika-srpska-should-beset-up/.

Politika Online. (2022, 7 February). Djukanović: Odbranili smo Crnu Goru od velikosrpskog nacionalizma. https://www.politika.rs/scc/clanak/498966/Dukanovic-Odbranilismo-CrnuGoru-od-velikosrpskognacionalizma?fbclid=IwAR06Sm2qlK_2k7mDvf1MqRAVpCTPvLWU6kQQI0832bZOCofriR47r3hSPw.

Popov, Č. (2008). Velika Srbija: Stvarnost ili mit [Greater Serbia: Reality or Myth]. Izdavačka knjižara Zorana Stojanovića.

Radio Slobodna Evropa. (2021, 19 July). Vučić o ’srpskom svetu’: Zvanična politika je da su granice Srbije nepovredive, tuđe nas ne zanimaju. https://www.slobodnaevropa .org/a/vucic-srpskisvet-granice-/31367043.html.

Raković, A. (2022). Srpstvo i Pravoslavlje: Istorija, vera, politika II [Serbia and Orthodoxy: History, Religion, Politcs II]. Institut za evropske studije.

Sandžačke. (2022, 30 August). Pahor: Beograd da odustane od ’srpskog sveta’ i podrške separatističkim nastojanjima u BiH. https://sandzacke.rs/featured/ pahor-beograd-da-odustane-odsrpskog-sveta-i-podrske-separatistickim-nastojanjima-u-bih/.

Schneider, C. & Wagemann, C. (2012). Set-theoretic methods for the Social Sciences: A Guide to Qualitative Comparative Analysis. Cambridge University Press.

Sloboden pečat. (2020). Djukanović: The term ’Serbian world’ is a euphemism for the idea of a greater Serbia. https://www.slobodenpecat.mk/en/gukanovik-izrazot-srpskisvet-e-eufemizam-za-idejata-za-golema-srbija/.

Spalović, D. (2022, 5 January). Bauk ’srpskog sveta’ je postao politički biznis. Politika Online. https://www.politika.rs/scc/clanak/496321/Bauk-srpskog-svetaje-postao-politicki-biznis.

Stanković, J. (2021, 18 July). Vulin: Srpski svet bi trebalo da bude jedan politički prostor, jedna država. Dnevni list Danas. https://www.danas.rs/vesti/politika/vulin-srpski-svet-bi-trebaloda-bude-jedan-politicki-prostor-jedna-drzava/.

Tursić, N. (2024, 17 August). Analiza Doktora Tursića: ’Srpski svet’ je moderna verzija projekta ’Velika Srbija’!. Slobodna Bosna. https://www.slobodnabosna.ba/vijest/363991/analiza_doktora_tursica_srpski_svet_je_moderna_verzija_projekta_velika_srbija.html#goog_rewarded.

Uredništvo srpskog sveta. (2022, 4 September). Narodni ministar: Ili ćemo stvoriti srpski svet ili nas neće biti [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9rFitVJk9w.

Vehnari, G. (2023, 4 June). Kosovski premijer Albin Kurti za The Geopost: Putin je opsjednut Kosovom, Srbija pokreće hibridni rat. Istraga. https://istraga.ba/kosovski-premijer-albin-kurtiza-the-gepost-putin-je-opsjednut-kosovom-srbija-pokrece-hibridni-rat/.

Vukićević, J. & Tuhina, G. (2021). ’Srpski svet’ – koncept koji region čini nervoznim. Radio Slobodna Evropa. https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/srpski-svet-srbija-balkan- /31521168.html.

Zhang, Y. & Wildemuth, M. B. (2009). Qualitative Analysis of Content. In Wildemuth M. B. (Ed.), Applications of Social Research Methods to Questions in Information and Library Science (pp. 1–12). Libraries Unlimited.

Žutić, N. (2016). Velika Srbija 1888-1926: Istoriografska analiza listova Velika Srbija [Greater Serbia 1888-1926: A Historiographical Analysis of The Greater Serbia Newspapers]. Institut za savremenu istoriju.