MISUSE OF ETHNIC IDENTITIES IN THE BALKANS AS A POTENTIAL FOR EXTREMIST EXPRESSION
Keywords:
Balkans, identity, ethnos, ethno nationalism, religion, extremismAbstract
Most of the conflicts in modern world represent a product of identity confrontations based on issues of ethnicity, religion and culture. After getting an adequate stimulus, identity conscience present within one group of people easily transforms into a powerful weapon for brutal treating another group. The former SFR Yugoslavia met the end of eight decade of 20th century as a mostly atheist or agnostic society. At the same time, it was inhabited by ethnicities which used to build their identity particularly holding on religious affiliation. Such circumstances, along with weakening of the state in second half of eighties, caused a rapid rise of nationalism, which often used to be expressed through instrumentalization of religious sentiments. Serbian political elites used to identify their national interest with the space inhabited by numerous believers of the Serbian Orthodox Church. Croatian elites advocated an ideology of defending Catholicism while the Bosnian ones used to build their identity on the basis of belonging to the Islamic religious community. A policy of intolerance, as well as of untouchable ethnic and religious identities contributed to the outbreak of the civil war and to maintenance of the illusion that the war was inevitable. Besides elaboration of the phenomenon, this work aims to answer the question: whether identity-based differences in terms of ethnicity and religion represent an inconclusive cause of confrontation or conflicts in the Balkans are a product of conscious manipulation over those identity marks, performed by political factors. Also the work highlights ambivalent, often even incestuous attitude of political establishments in countries of so called western democracy. Namely, Western Europeans are inclined to observe events in Balkans as relicts of archaic ages and products of uncivilized barbarians. Europe with the corp of its established democratic values is yet not (and must not be) alienated from what happens in the Balkans. „Problems induced in so called weak states spill over the region with unbealivable easiness, and increasingly reach even states thousands of kilometеrs away which are considered as developed democracies“ (Milenković, Subotić, 2017: 57). Exactly the interweaving of ethnic, religious, cultural and linguistic elements makes the Balkans an paradigm in which intra-European conflicts for statehood, language, ethnicity and even religion meet, reaching an accentuated and distorted form.
Downloads
References
Asurmendi, Mikel (ur.), (2002): Identitet i nasilje, XX vek, Beograd
Atanacković, Petar (2012): „Od nacionalizma do neonacizma“, u: Desni ekstremizam – ultradesničarske i neonacističke grupacije na prostoru bivše SFRJ, Alternativna kulturna organizacija i Rosa Luxemburg Southeast Europe, Novi Sad
Barthazi, Eszter (2008): „Manipuláció, valamint manipulációra alkalmas nyelvhasználati eszközök a sajtóreklámokban“, Magyar Nyelv 104: 443–463, u: Urkom, Aleksandar (2015) „Migracija identiteta - identitetska obeležja i njihova manipulacija“, Godišnjak Fakulteta za kulturu i medije br. 7, Beograd, str. 483-498.
Benda, Žilijen (1996): Izdaja intelektualaca, Socijalna misao, Beograd
Bourdieu, Pierre (1993): Sociology in Question, prev. Richard Nice, London, Sage
BiEPAG, „The Crisis of Democracy in the Western Balkans – Authoritarianism and EU Stabilitocracy“, Policy Paper: Balkans in Europe Policy Advisory Group, March 2017.
Bugarski, Ranko (2010): Jezik i identitet, Beograd, Biblioteka XX vek
Crawford, James (2006): The Creation of States in International Law, Second Edition, Oxford, Clarendon Press
Despotović, LJ., Jevtović, Z. (2014): „Geopolitički aspekti razaranja nacionalnih država i identiteta na prostoru zapadnog Balkana“, u: (Dez)integracija država i identitet (ur. Milošević, Z., Đurić, Ž.), Institut za političke studije, Beograd
Dahlitz, Julie (2003): Secession and International Law, Conflict Avoidance; Regional Appraisals, The Hague, TMC Asser Press, 2003.
De Benoist, Alain (2011): „Mi i Drugi - Što je to identitet?“, predavanje u Matici hrvatskoj na temu budućnosti identiteta, 14. april 2011.
Đukanović, Dragan (2007): Institucionalni modeli i demokratizacija postjugoslovenskih država, Institut za međunarodnu politiku i privredu, Beograd.
Ekonomist: “Stabilokratija recept za nestabilnost”, u: http://www.novimagazin.rs/vesti/ekonomist-stabilokratija-recept-za-nestabilnost-vucicuglavni-protivnik-jeremi , 11/2/2018.
“Fragile States Index 2015”, The Fund for Peace, Washington
Hejden, Robert M. (2003): Skice za podeljenu kuću: ustavna logika jugoslovenskih sukoba, Samizdat B92
Kecmanović, Nenad (2014): Etnonacionalizam, Izabrana dela; 1-4; tom 2, Clio, Beograd, 2014.
King, Charles (2011): “The Myth of Ethnic Warfare”, Foreign Affairs 80/6.
Mijatović B., Vujačić I., Marinković T. (2008): Pojmovnik liberalne demokratije, Službeni glasnik i Centar za liberalno-demokratske studije, Beograd
Milenković, M., Subotić, M. (2017): „Nasilni nedržavni akteri i pozicija Srbije“, Srpska politička misao, Institut za političke studije, Beograd 3/2017 (55-70)
Pavković, A., Radan, P. (2008): Stvaranje novih država, teorija i praksa otcepljenja, Beograd, Službeni glasnik
Russel, Hardin (1982): Collective Action. Baltimore, USA: The Johns Hopkins University Press
Savater, Fernando (2002): „Tri kratka ogleda o nacionalizmu i terorizmu“ (203-208), u: Mikel Asurmendi (ur.), Identitet i nasilje, XX vek, Beograd
Sen, Amartya (2007): Identitet i nasilje – iluzija sudbine, Masmedia, Zagreb
Sen, Amartya (1987): On Ethics and Economics, Oxford, Blackwell
Schenkkan, Nate (2017): Nation in Transit: The False Promise of Populism, Freedom House
Subotić, Milovan (2018): „Ekstremističke tendencije u AP Vojvodini“, Kultura polisa, posebno izdanje 1/2018, Novi Sad (171-185)
Subotić, Milovan (2015): Ekstremizam pod okriljem religije, Medija centar Odbrana i Institut za strategijska istraživanja, Beograd
Subotić, Milovan, Dimitrijević Ivan (2018): „Ekstremizam na Zapadnom Balkanu kao prepreka proklamovanoj politici EU o pomirenju i dobrosusedskim odnosima“, Srbija i svet u 2017. godini, priredili: D. Proroković, V. Trapara, (67-88), Institut za međunarodnu politiku i privredu, Beograd
Šušnjić, Đuro (2009): Religija II, značenja, teorije, preplitanja, susreti, Čigoja štampa, Beograd
Štrbac K., Subotić, M., Milosavljević, B. (2012): „Extremist Trends in the Western Balkans and the Republic of Serbia“, Journal on Law, Economy & Management, Science Centre Ltd. pp. 92-97
Taylor, Charles (1995): Sources of the Seifand the Making of the Modern Identity, Cambridge, Mass, Harvard University Press
Tirole, Jean (2002): "Rational Irrationality: Some Economics of Self-management", European Economic Revue, 46.
The Economist, “The West backs Balkan autocrats to keep the peace, again”, https://www.economist.com/news/europe/21724414-some-call-it-stabilitocracy-otherscall-it-way-things-have-always-been-west-backs-balkan 19/2/2018
Urkom, Aleksandar (2015): “Migracija identiteta - identitetska obeležja i njihova manipulacija”, Godišnjak Fakulteta za kulturu i medije br. 7, Beograd, str. 483-498.
Vukadinović, Srđan (2002): „Građanska povezanost mnoštva identiteta kao vrijednost društava Jugoistočne Evrope“, Kulturni i etnički identiteti u procesu globalizacije i regionalizacije Balkana, priredili Lj. Mitrović, D. B. Đorđević i D. Todorović, 250-254. Niš: Centar za balkanske studije i JUNIR