MICHEL MAFFESOLI: BETWEEN CIVILIZATIONAL CRISIS AND SOFT TOTALITARIANISM, A LOOK AT TODAY'S FRANCE, BOTH CONFLICTUAL AND COMMUNITARIAN
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51738/Kpolisa2024.21.1r.144tKeywords:
Protest movements, civilizational crisis, soft-totalitarianism, scientism, communitarianism, FranceAbstract
Sociologist, Professor, and, among other positions, holder of the “Emile Durkheim” chair at the Sorbonne, and director of the Center for Research on the Imaginary, Michel Maffesoli is an essential personality in the French academic-media landscape. Although he is often contested as a scientist, he nonetheless remains an enlightened observer of postmodernity and his socio-political analyzes on various themes linked to societal developments remain references with strong prophetic value, whatever his detractors may say. In his essay The era of uprisings (Maffesoli, 2021), he is a critical observer of the growing divorce between political-media elites and French citizens which is manifested by the multiplication of protest movements. This thesis leads us to go beyond conventional interpretations of poverty or inequalities in order to understand the extent of the civilizational crisis we are experiencing and the transition to after-modernity. The latter serves as a preamble to a denunciation of ‘soft totalitarianism’ and the rejection of human finitude which are rampant today in France since the Covid-19 pandemic. Furthermore, and perhaps paradoxically, it fuels ‘the trial of utopian imagination’ (Wunenburger, 1978) while calling for the revival of a revolutionary spirit. This review essay aims at 1) putting the author's arguments into perspective with previous but also current works in order to gain impartiality, and 2) comparing the achievements of the work with socio-political aspects touched upon or even ignored, this which makes it possible to extend the political and social scope of the analysis.
Downloads
References
Allaire, B. (1978). Michel Maffesoli; Logique de la domination ; Collection sociologie d'aujourd'hui. Paris: P.U.F., 1976 [Michel Maffesoli; Logic of domination]. Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue Canadienne De Science Politique, 11, 220–223.
Amossy, R. (2023). “Health Dictatorship” and “Civil Disobedience”: Political extremists and French debates on democracy during Covid-19. Javnost-The Public, 30, 18-34.
Artus, P., & Marie-Paule Virard, M-P. (2018). Et si les salariés se révoltaient ? [What if employees rose up ?]. Fayard.
Autour du livre : Le Temps des peurs (2023) – entretien avec Michel Maffesoli par Jean-Marie Seca [Around the book: The Time of Fears (2023) – interview with Michel Maffesoli by Jean-Marie Seca] (2023, July 27). Le Courrier des Stratèges. https://lecourrierdesstrateges.fr/2023/07/24/autour-du-livrele-temps-des-peurs-2023-interview-avec-michel-maffesoli-etrecension-par-jean-marie-seca/
Bjelajac, Ž. (2014). Alijenacija čoveka u eri naučnotehnološkog razvoja i globalizacije kao uzrok porasta i raznolikosti organizovanog kriminala [Human Alienation in the Era of Scientific and Technological Development and Globalization as a Cause of Increase and Diversity of Organized Crime]. Kultura polisa, 11(25): 385–396.
Bjelajac, Ž., & Matijašević, J. (2013). Nasilje kao oblik socio-patološkog ponašanja [Violence as a Form of Sociopathological Behavior]. Kultura polisa,10(22): 409–425.
Bondy Blog (2023). Qui sommes-nous ? [Who are we?]. Bondy Blog. https://www.bondyblog.fr/
Citot, V. (2005). Le processus historique de la modernité et la possibilité de la liberté (universalisme et individualisme) [The historical process of modernity and the possibility of freedom (universalism and individualism)]. Le Philosophoire, 25(2), 35–76. https://doi.org/10.3917/phoir.025.0035
Colliot-Thélène, C. (2021). Violence policière, violence d’État [Police violence, State violence]. Savoir/Agir, 55(1), 33–39. https://doi.org/10.3917/sava.055.0033
Comment l’imaginaire révolutionnaire français perdure à travers le mouvement des Gilets Jaunes [How the French revolutionary imagination endures through the Yellow Vest movement]. (2019, August 9). LVSL. https://lvsl.fr/comment-limaginairerevolutionnaire-francais-perdure-a-travers-les-mouvements-gil ets-jaunes-dans-le-monde/
Escalona, F. (2023, April 1). “Monopole de la violence légitime”: La foire aux contresens [“Monopoly of legitimate violence”: The fair of misinterpretations]. Mediapart. https://www.mediapart.fr/journal/politique/010423/monopolede-la-violence-legitime-la-foire-aux-contresens
Evola, J. (1934). Révolte contre le monde moderne [Revolt against the modern world]. Paris : L'Âge d'homme.
Fougeyrollas, P. (1991). Michel Maffesoli; Au creux des apparences. Pour une éthique de l'esthétique ; Paris : Plon, 1990 [In the hollow of appearances. For an ethics of aesthetics ; Paris: Plon, 1990]. L'Homme et la société, Théorie du sujet et théorie sociale, 101, 149–151.
Guénon, R. (1927/2021). La crise du monde moderne [The crisis of the modern world]. République des Lettres.
Guillaud, F. (2005). La modernité : Crise d'adolescence de l'humanité ? [Modernity: Humanity's adolescent crisis ?]. Le Philosophoire, 25(2), 77-88. https://doi.org/10.3917/phoir.025.0077
Guilluy, C. (2015). La France périphérique. Comment on a sacrifié les classes populaires [Peripheral France. How we sacrificed the working classes]. Flammarion.
Hermann, E., & Chomsky, N. (2020). Fabriquer un consentement: La gestion politique des médias de masse (Edition française) [Manufacturing consent: The political ecomomy of the Mass media (French edition)]. Investig’Action. Kindle Edition.
Haupt, A. (2023). De la société pharmaco-punitive au crédit social [From the pharmaco-punitive society to social credit]. Kindle Edition.
Juignet, P. (2015). Karl Popper et les critères de la scientificité [Karl Popper and the criteria of scientificity]. Philosophy, science and society. https://philosciences.com/112
Klein, Naomi. (2007). The shock doctrine: The rise of disaster capitalism. Macmillan.
La lectio divina ou lecture priante de la Bible [Lectio divina or prayerful reading of the Bible] (2023). Paroisse Dinard-Pleurtuit. https://paroissedinardpleurtuit.fr/la-lectio-divina/
Lalande, A. (2010). Vocabulaire technique et critique de la philosophie [Technical and critical vocabulary of philosophy]. P.U.F., coll. “Quadrige”.
Laporte, A. (1894/2012). Émile Zola, l'homme et l’œuvre: Le naturalisme ou l'immortalité littéraire ; Suivi de la bibliographie de ses ouvrages et de la liste des ecrivains qui ont ecrit pour ou contre lui [Émile Zola, the man and the work: Naturalism or literary immortality ; Followed by the bibliography of his works and the list of writers who wrote for or against him] . Gautherin. Nabu Press.
Landi, S. (2011). Opinions et conflits : Une relecture des histoires de Florence de Machiavel [Opinions and conflicts: A rereading of Machiavelli's stories of Florence]. Revue Française d’Histoire des Idées Politiques, 33(1), 137–162. https://doi.org/10.3917/rfhip.033.0137
Maffesoli, M. (1976). Logique de la domination [Logic of domination]. Paris : P.U.F.
Maffesoli, M. (1988). Le temps des tribus : Le déclin de l'individualisme dans les sociétés de masse [The time of the tribes: The decline of individualism in mass societies]. Méridiens-Klincksieck.
Maffesoli, M. (1990). Au creux des apparences. Pour une éthique de l'esthétique [In the hollow of appearances. For an ethics of aesthetics]. Plon.
Maffesoli, M. (2008). Après la modernité ? – Logique de la domination, la violence totalitaire, la conquête du présent [After modernity? – The logic of domination, totalitarian violence, the conquest of the present]. CNRS éditions.
Maffesoli, M. (2019, January 8). Gilets jaunes : les ronds-points, cet «Aventin» moderne [Yellow vests: roundabouts, this modern “Aventine”]. Le Point. https://www.lepoint.fr/debats/giletsjaunes-les-ronds-points-cet-aventin-moderne-08-01-2019-228 4014_2.php
Maffesoli, M., & Strohl. H. (2019). La faillite des élites : La puissance de l'idéal communautaire [The bankruptcy of elites: The power of the community ideal]. Les Editions du Cerf.
Maffesoli, M. (2021). L’ère des soulèvements [The era of uprisings]. Les Editions du Cerf.
Maffesoli, M. (2023). Le temps des peurs [The time of fears]. Les Editions du Cerf.
Maffesoli, M., & Strohl. H. (2023, August 6). Michel Maffesoli & Hélène Strohl – Soulèvements vers l’idéal communautaire – Tribune présentée par le Cercle Maupeou de Montpellier [Michel Maffesoli & Hélène Strohl – Uprisings towards the community ideal – Tribune presented by the Cercle Maupeou of Montpellier]. Le Cercle Aristote. https://cerclearistote.fr/michel-maffesolihelene-strohl-soulevements-communautaire-tribune-cercle-ma upeou/
Mucchielli, L. (2008). La frénésie sécuritaire. Retour à l’ordre et nouveau contrôle social [The security hysteria. Return to order and new social control]. La Découverte.
Nadeau, C. (2003). Machiavel, domination et liberté politique [Machiavelli, domination and political freedom]. Philosophiques, 30(2), 321-351. https://doi.org/10.7202/008644ar
Petit, A. (1987). Ernest Renan : Militant des humanités [Ernest Renan: Humanities activist]. Études Renaniennes, 69, 3-22. https://doi.org/10.3406/renan.1987.1352
Piot, F. (2002). L'Idéal communautaire, mythe fondateur et utopie créatrice : Essai de mythosociologie [The Community Ideal, founding myth and creative utopia: Essay on mythosociology]. Doctoral Dissertation, Paris 5.
Popper, K. (1974/1981). Autobiographie intellectuelle de 1974: La quête inachevée [Intellectual autobiography of 1974: The unfinished quest]. Presses Pocket.
Renaut, A. (1989). L’ère de l’individu. Contribution à une histoire de la subjectivité [The era of the individual. Contribution to a history of subjectivity]. Bibliothèque des idées, Gallimard.
Saidi-Cottier, N., & Ferey, M. (2020, December 4). 5 années de lois liberticides en France []. Journee Internationale des Droits de l’Homme. http://aadh.fr/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/5- anne%CC%81es-de-loi-liberticides-en-France.pdf
Scappaticci, E. (2017, February 21). Minute : la séquence bons sentiments de Mehdi Meklat [Minute: the good feelings sequence of Mehdi Meklat]. Le Figaro/Culture. https://www.lefigaro.fr/livres/2017/02/21/03005- 20170221ARTFIG00330--minute-la-sequence-bons-sentimentsde-mehdi-meklat.php
Schlegel, J-L. (2021). Vers une dictature sanitaire ? [Towards a health dictatorship?]. Esprit, October.https://esprit.presse.fr/actualites /jean-louis-schlegel/vers-une-dictature-sanitaire-43592
Schwab, K., & Malleret, T. (2020). Covid 19, The great reset. Forum Publishing.
Wikiberal (2011, December 6). Les dangers du scientisme [The dangers of scientism]. Contrepoints. https://www.contrepoints.org/2011/12/06/59194-les-dangersdu-scientisme
Wunenburger, J-J. (1978). L'utopie ou la crise de l'imaginaire [Utopia or the crisis of imagination]. FeniXX.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Laurent Tournois
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.